Violation Removal Services
Violation Removal
Open violations block permits, delay closings, trigger liens, and compound over time. Post & Lintel coordinates the full resolution process for DOB and ECB violations — from identifying what's open and why, through the physical correction, Certificate of Correction filing, and OATH penalty resolution across all five boroughs.
In New York City, a DOB violation and an ECB fine are two separate things — and resolving one does not automatically resolve the other.
The NYC Department of Buildings issued over 450,000 violations across the five boroughs in 2024 alone. A DOB violation is a citation for a building code or permit infraction — it is corrected by addressing the underlying physical condition and filing a Certificate of Correction. An ECB (Environmental Control Board) violation is the civil penalty attached to that citation, processed through the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH). Both must be resolved independently: fixing the condition closes the DOB violation; paying or settling the fine closes the ECB obligation.
The consequences of leaving violations unresolved compound over time. Unpaid ECB fines accrue 9% annual interest, convert to property liens after 60 days, and block permit issuance on the building. Open DOB violations appear in title searches and can derail closings, refinancing, and co-op board approvals. Stop Work Orders issued on active jobs shut down construction until the underlying condition is resolved and the order is rescinded. Understanding what is open and what each violation requires — before deadlines pass — is the starting point for any violation resolution strategy.
DOB Violations vs. ECB/OATH Violations
One of the most common sources of confusion in NYC violation resolution is the distinction between DOB violations and ECB/OATH violations. They arise from the same incident but are tracked, processed, and resolved through entirely separate systems.
DOB Violation
A citation issued by the Department of Buildings documenting a specific building code or permit infraction. Tracked in the DOB Building Information System (BIS) and DOB NOW. Resolved by correcting the physical condition and filing a Certificate of Correction with the DOB. The DOB may re-inspect to verify correction before marking the violation as resolved. Appears on property records indefinitely — paid and dismissed violations remain in the DOB database.
ECB / OATH Violation
The civil penalty summons attached to a DOB (or other agency) violation. Processed through OATH — the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings. Must be resolved by paying the fine, entering a stipulation, or contesting at an OATH hearing. A single incident can generate both a DOB violation and an ECB summons that must be resolved separately. Unpaid fines become property liens after 60 days and accrue 9% annual interest.
Violation Classes
The DOB classifies violations into three classes based on severity, each with different cure deadlines and penalty ranges. Understanding which class applies determines the urgency of response and the resolution path.
Class 1 — Immediately Hazardous
Conditions posing an immediate threat to public safety — including illegal construction, structural instability, blocked egress, and work without a permit on critical systems. Require immediate correction. ECB penalties range from $2,500 to $25,000 or more. Failure to miss the hearing results in a penalty five times the standard amount. These violations also block permit issuance on the building until resolved.
Class 2 — Major
Significant but not immediately hazardous conditions — including failure to maintain building façade, missing fire safety equipment, elevator safety deficiencies, and energy compliance failures. Carry a cure date on the violation notice. If corrected and a Certificate of Correction is filed by the cure date, no hearing is required and no penalty is imposed. Penalties if uncured range from $500 to $10,000 depending on violation type.
Class 3 — Minor
Lower-severity conditions involving record-keeping, administrative non-compliance, or minor maintenance issues. Still require resolution and Certificate of Correction filing. ECB fines for Class 3 violations typically range from $250 to $2,500. While individually smaller, accumulated minor violations can create a significant aggregate penalty exposure on properties with long-standing compliance gaps.
The Most Frequently Issued DOB Violations in NYC
The following are among the most commonly issued DOB violation types in New York City. Each carries its own resolution requirements — some requiring only administrative action, others requiring physical work, permit filings, and professional sign-off before the violation can be closed.
Work Without a Permit
The single most common DOB violation — accounting for approximately 41–47% of all ECB summonses. Issued when construction, demolition, plumbing, electrical, or other regulated work is performed without a valid DOB permit. Legalization requires filing as-built drawings, obtaining a permit retroactively, completing required inspections, and paying a surcharge of double the standard permit fee in addition to the ECB penalty.
Illegal Conversion / Occupancy
Issued for unauthorized changes of use — including illegal basement apartments, cellar conversions without a Certificate of Occupancy, or conversion of single-family homes to multi-unit occupancy. Resolution requires either legalizing the conversion through the DOB filing process or restoring the space to its permitted use — both of which require design documentation and permit approval.
Failure to Maintain — Façade / Parapet
Issued for failure to maintain exterior walls, parapets, cornices, or other building elements in a safe condition. Typically triggered by FISP inspection findings, 311 complaints, or DOB inspector observations. Resolution requires completing the required repairs, obtaining any necessary permits, and filing a Certificate of Correction. For FISP-related conditions, an amended FISP report is also required.
Elevator Violations
Issued for expired elevator inspection certificates, failed elevator tests, or operation of an elevator without a current Certificate of Operation. Resolution requires completing the required inspection or repair, passing a DOB elevator inspection, and filing the Certificate of Correction. Elevators with outstanding violations may be ordered out of service.
Boiler and Mechanical Violations
Issued for expired boiler inspection certificates, operation without a current certificate of fitness, or mechanical system deficiencies. Annual boiler inspections are required by the DOB for most steam and hot water boilers in NYC. Resolution requires completing the required inspection, obtaining the certificate, and filing the Certificate of Correction.
Stop Work Order Violations
Issued when construction proceeds in violation of an active Stop Work Order — one of the most serious violation categories in the DOB enforcement system. Resolving SWO violations requires correcting the underlying condition that triggered the order, obtaining DOB approval to rescind the SWO, and in many cases appearing before OATH. Continuing to work after an SWO is issued dramatically increases penalty exposure.
FISP / Local Law 11 Violations
Issued for failure to file a FISP report within the applicable sub-cycle window, or for Unsafe façade conditions that require immediate correction. Late filing penalties accrue at $1,000 per month from the missed deadline. Unsafe conditions carry additional ECB penalties and require immediate public protection measures. Resolution requires filing the FISP report, completing required repairs, and filing the amended report.
Energy Compliance Violations
Issued for failure to file required energy compliance reports — including the LL87 Energy Efficiency Report and LL84 benchmarking submissions. LL87 non-compliance carries a $3,000 penalty for the first year and $5,000 for each subsequent year of non-compliance. Resolution requires completing the underlying audit or benchmarking submission and filing the Certificate of Correction confirming compliance.
Responding to ECB Summonses Through OATH
When an ECB summons is issued, the recipient has 30 days to respond. There are four primary response options, each appropriate for different circumstances. Missing the response deadline entirely results in an automatic default judgment at five times the standard penalty amount — one of the most expensive outcomes in the NYC violation system.
The Four Response Options
Admit and Pay
If the violation is accurate and correction is complete, paying the standard penalty within 30 days waives the right to a hearing but avoids additional penalties and interest. A 10% early-payment discount is available for online payment within the initial response window. Use when the violation is accurate and the penalty is reasonable.
Cure — Certificate of Correction
For Class 2 and certain Class 3 violations with a cure date on the violation notice: correct the physical condition and file a valid Certificate of Correction with the DOB on or before the cure date. If approved, no hearing appearance is required and no OATH penalty is imposed. This is the most favorable outcome — the violation is resolved without a fine.
Stipulation
For certain violations, owners may enter a pre-hearing stipulation — admitting guilt in exchange for 75 additional days to correct the violating condition. Reduces the penalty but requires admitting liability. Available for violations where correction is underway but cannot be completed before the hearing date. Must be arranged before the first scheduled OATH hearing.
Contest at OATH Hearing
Request a hearing to contest the violation before an OATH Administrative Law Judge. Hearings are available by video (Webex) or in person. If the violation is corrected before the hearing date and proof is brought to the hearing, the ALJ may reduce the penalty by 50% or more. Approximately 38% of contested violations are dismissed or reduced. Dismissal is possible where the violation never occurred, the inspector made a factual error, or the work was authorized.
Default Judgments and Liens
Failure to respond to an ECB summons within the applicable window results in a default judgment at five times the standard penalty. After 60 days without payment, OATH files a lien on the property — which accrues 9% annual interest and must be satisfied before the property can be sold or refinanced. Property liens appear in title searches and are among the most common obstacles discovered during real estate closings and co-op board review of purchaser applications. The city may also pursue debt collection, bank account seizure, and rent garnishment to recover unpaid OATH judgments.
Vacating Default Judgments
If a default judgment has been entered because the property owner did not receive or respond to the summons, it may be possible to file a Motion to Vacate Default within 30 days of learning of the default. The motion must demonstrate: a reasonable excuse for the default (such as a mail delivery issue or incorrect address on record) and a meritorious defense to the underlying violation. If granted, the case is reopened for a hearing on the merits.
Stop Work Orders — Response and Rescission
A Stop Work Order (SWO) is among the most disruptive enforcement actions the DOB can take on an active construction project. All construction work must cease immediately upon issuance. Continuing to work after a SWO is posted is a separate, serious violation that dramatically increases penalty exposure.
What Triggers a Stop Work Order
The DOB may issue a Stop Work Order when construction is found to be proceeding without a valid permit, deviating from approved drawings in a material way, creating an unsafe condition on or adjacent to the site, violating a prior DOB directive, or being performed by an unlicensed contractor in a category requiring licensure. SWOs may also be issued in response to 311 complaints, accidents, or observations by DOB field inspectors.
Rescinding a Stop Work Order
To rescind a SWO, the owner and contractor must correct the underlying condition that triggered the order, demonstrate to the DOB that the corrective action is complete, and in many cases appear before a DOB supervisor or, if an ECB penalty is also attached, before OATH. The specific rescission process depends on the type of SWO — some can be rescinded by a DOB field inspector upon re-inspection; others require formal DOB office review. Until the SWO is formally rescinded, no permitted work may resume on the affected job.
Full vs. Partial Stop Work Orders
A full SWO stops all permitted work on a job. A partial SWO limits the restriction to a specific portion of the scope — for example, structural work — while allowing other permitted work to continue. Understanding the scope of the SWO issued is important in determining what, if anything, can continue while the resolution process is underway. Post & Lintel reviews the SWO documentation to clarify the scope and coordinates the response accordingly.
Legalizing Unpermitted Work
Work Without a Permit (WWP) is the most frequently cited DOB violation in New York City — accounting for approximately 41% of all ECB summonses in 2024. It arises whenever regulated construction, demolition, plumbing, electrical, or other permitted work is performed without a valid DOB permit, whether by the current owner, a prior owner, or an unlicensed contractor.
The Legalization Process
Legalizing unpermitted work requires filing as-built drawings that accurately document the work as it was constructed — not as it may have been originally designed. These drawings must be prepared by a licensed architect or engineer, submitted to the DOB through DOB NOW, and approved through the standard plan examination or Professional Certification process. Once plans are approved, a retroactive permit is issued, required inspections must be completed, and a final sign-off must be obtained before the DOB violation can be closed with a Certificate of Correction.
The Double Permit Fee Surcharge
In addition to ECB penalties, buildings legalizing work performed without a permit are subject to a surcharge equal to double the standard permit fee under NYC Administrative Code §28-105.4. This surcharge applies at the time the retroactive permit is issued and is in addition to — not in lieu of — the ECB penalty for the WWP violation itself.
When Legalization Is Not Possible
Not all unpermitted work can be legalized. If the work as constructed does not comply with current zoning regulations or building code requirements, and cannot be brought into compliance through design modifications, the DOB may require the work to be partially or fully removed. In these cases, the violation resolution strategy must include removal scope, permit filings for the removal work, inspections confirming the removal, and Certificate of Correction filing. Post & Lintel assesses legalization feasibility before advising on the resolution path.
Violations Discovered During Sale or Refinancing
Open DOB violations, unpaid ECB fines, and property liens are among the most common issues discovered during real estate transactions in New York City. They appear in title searches, are reviewed by lenders and co-op boards, and if not resolved before closing, can derail or delay transactions at significant cost.
Timing Is Critical
Resolving violations in advance of a closing requires adequate lead time — 60 days minimum for straightforward cases, 90 days or more for situations involving permit filings, plan examination, physical work, and re-inspection. Starting the process after a title search surfaces violations at contract signing is almost always too late for a timely close. Property owners who anticipate a sale or refinancing within 12 months should conduct a violation audit in advance and address open items before they become transaction obstacles.
What Title Companies and Lenders Review
Title searches pull all open DOB violations, unpaid ECB fines, OATH judgments, and property liens from the DOB Building Information System (BIS), DOB NOW, and the OATH violation database. For co-op sales, the board package review typically includes a BIS search as well. Open violations and unpaid fines flagged at this stage must either be resolved before closing or be the subject of a negotiated escrow holdback — an arrangement that is common but imposes its own costs and complications.
How Post & Lintel Approaches Violation Resolution
Post & Lintel Violation Removal Services
Post & Lintel manages violation resolution on behalf of building owners, property managers, and project teams — coordinating physical correction, permit filings, agency communications, and OATH penalty resolution across all violation types.
- DOB violation audit and status review
- ECB / OATH summons review
- BIS and DOB NOW violation search
- OATH judgment and lien identification
- Resolution strategy development
- Work Without a Permit legalization
- As-built drawing coordination
- DOB permit filing for legalization
- Plan examination and objection response
- Illegal conversion resolution
- Façade violation resolution coordination
- FISP violation response
- Parapet violation response
- Boiler inspection coordination
- Elevator violation coordination
- Energy compliance violation (LL84/87) resolution
- Stop Work Order response and rescission
- Certificate of Correction preparation and filing
- DOB re-inspection scheduling
- OATH hearing preparation support
- Stipulation coordination
- Default judgment vacatur support
- Lien clearance coordination
- Pre-closing violation resolution
Clients and Situations
Post & Lintel has supported violation resolution across a range of building types, ownership structures, and situations throughout New York City's five boroughs.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I find out what violations are open on my building?
Open DOB violations can be searched by address through the DOB Building Information System (BIS) at a.bisa.nyc.gov, and through DOB NOW. ECB/OATH summonses can be searched through the OATH violation search portal at oath.cityofnewyork.us. Both searches should be run — a violation appearing in one system may not appear in the other, and both must be resolved independently.
Does paying an ECB fine close the DOB violation?
No. Paying the ECB fine resolves the civil penalty obligation but does not close the underlying DOB violation. The DOB violation is closed separately by correcting the physical condition and filing a Certificate of Correction. Conversely, filing a Certificate of Correction does not automatically pay the ECB fine. Both must be resolved through their respective systems.
What happens if I miss my OATH hearing date?
Missing a scheduled OATH hearing results in an automatic default judgment at five times the standard penalty amount — with no opportunity to present evidence or contest the violation. If you learn of a default judgment within 30 days, it may be possible to file a Motion to Vacate Default by demonstrating a reasonable excuse for the miss and a meritorious defense to the underlying violation. Beyond 30 days, vacating a default is significantly more difficult.
How long does it take to resolve violations before a closing?
The timeline depends on the number and type of violations, whether physical work is required, and whether permit filings are needed. Simple violations resolvable by Certificate of Correction may take 30–60 days from start to BIS update. Violations requiring permit filings, plan examination, physical work, and re-inspection can take 90 days or more. Starting at least 60–90 days before a target closing date is strongly recommended — 90 days is better for complex situations.
Can ECB violations be dismissed?
Yes — at an OATH hearing, if you can demonstrate that the violation never occurred, the inspector made a factual error, the work was corrected before the inspection, or you had valid authorization. According to DOB Guard's analysis of 2024 OATH data, approximately 38% of contested violations are dismissed or reduced at hearings. Bringing proof of correction to the hearing — photos, permits, invoices — significantly improves the outcome. About 15% of contested violations are fully dismissed.
I inherited a property with old open violations — am I responsible?
Yes. DOB violations and ECB liens run with the property, not the individual owner. When a property is transferred, all open violations and unpaid fines transfer with it — including violations created by prior owners, contractors, or tenants. Title searches conducted before purchase are intended to surface these obligations. For properties acquired without a thorough title search, Post & Lintel can conduct a full violation audit and develop a resolution strategy.
What is a Certificate of Correction and how do I file one?
A Certificate of Correction (PW3 form) is the document filed with the DOB to certify that the condition cited in a DOB violation has been corrected. It is filed through DOB NOW or submitted to the applicable DOB borough office depending on the violation type. The certificate must describe the corrective action taken and include documentation such as photos, invoices, or contractor statements. Some violations require a DOB re-inspection to confirm correction before the violation is marked resolved.
Will a resolved violation be removed from my building's record?
No. ECB violations — including those that have been paid or dismissed — remain in the DOB and OATH databases permanently and appear in title searches. They are marked as resolved or dismissed, which is the relevant status for most transaction and compliance purposes, but they are not deleted. The DOB Building Information System reflects all violation history regardless of resolution status.
Have open violations that need to move? Reach out to discuss your building's violation history, a pending closing, or an active Stop Work Order.
Contact Us